Yes, and this (your first paragraph) was my point. The last 5 years was also the first 3 years of his life in the ACC. My point almost exactly. Could it be that he realized that his top-shelf old BE program could not compete in the amalgamated BE/ACC? I think probably so (with some nudges from a few well-placed Pitt insiders).
Here is where we differ. I struggle to see it as a win, except for the altruistic fact that TCU is his alma mater. I know that GTJT doesn't see it this way, but TCU is as dead-end as a men's basketball program gets in a P5 conference. I'll believe it until someone shows me otherwise. The state of GA has lots of players, too, but GA State is a dead-end job for men's basketball.
So my application is this: If a top-shelf coach leaves the ACC after yet another NCAAT bid and goes to a program like TCU (understanding that it is his alma mater), is that an advertisement for up and coming top-shelf mid-major coach to come and take a bottom 3rd GA Tech program? Will he see it for what we want him to see it as? That being a great opportunity. Or will he look at a guy like Dixon and say, good grief, do I really want to do that to myself? This is my speculation.
Just a thought. No real strong feeling on either side of this. But I don't think it can all be explained by his alma mater calling, IMHO.
But... we're about to begin the next 5 Year Plan TM. It will be interesting.
I don't think it is any harder to compete in the Big 12 than it is in the ACC. It may be harder to win a conference championship in the ACC since there are more teams, but not to finish with a winning record in conference and get to NCAATs. You obviously disagree with that, that's fine.
I don't think people in the basketball profession look at GT as a bottom 3rd program. GT has been in a slump but played in ACCCGs twice since a Final Four just 12 years ago. Since then GT has built great new facilities, sits in a good recruiting area, is located in a great, international city, etc.
Any basketball coach that should even be considered at any ACC school should be dying for an opportunity to prove they can win at the highest level. See Cremins as a perfect example. I know it is ancient history but human nature doesn't change due to conference composition.
I did almost drop a communist poster in there, by the way.